Titanium and tungsten are two extremely important metal materials in modern industry and high-tech fields. Although they are both transition metals, they have significant differences in physical properties, chemical properties, application fields, etc. This article will explore the main differences between these two metals in depth.
What is Titanium?
Titanium is a special metal that is known for being lightweight and resistant to rust. It is widely used in industries such as automotive, aerospace and medical technology. Titanium is also very strong, which is why it is so popular. It helps to increase the strength of products such as cars and aircraft without making them too heavy. With titanium, we can create products that are very durable, reliable and have excellent performance. Titanium is a wonder metal that has driven many advances in different fields.
What are the characteristics of Titanium?
Titanium is a metal with unique properties, which can be summarized as follows:
(1) Physical properties
| Property | Value/Description |
|---|---|
| Density | 4.506 g/cm³ (about 40% lighter than steel) |
| Melting point | 1668°C（3034°F） |
| Boiling point | 3287°C（5949°F） |
| Strength | Specific strength (strength/density ratio) is extremely high, better than steel and aluminum |
| Thermal conductivity | Low (17 W/m·K, about 1/30 of copper) |
| Electrical conductivity | Poor (high resistivity) |
| Magnetism | Non-magnetic (suitable for medical and electronic equipment) |
(2) Chemical properties
Corrosion resistance: A dense titanium oxide (TiO₂) protective layer is formed on the surface of titanium, making it almost corrosion-resistant in seawater, acid and alkaline environments.
Reactivity: Stable at room temperature, but easily reacts with oxygen, nitrogen, carbon, etc. at high temperatures.
Biocompatibility: Non-toxic, not rejected by the human body, widely used in medical implants.
(3) Mechanical properties
High toughness: Can withstand large impacts without breaking easily.
Low thermal expansion coefficient: Dimensionally stable when the temperature changes, suitable for precision instruments.
What are the different types of Titanium ?
Titanium can be classified by purity and alloy composition. Common types include:
(1) Pure titanium (commercially pure titanium, CP Ti)
| Grade | Main component | Characteristics | Application |
|---|---|---|---|
| Grade 1 | 99.5% Ti | Softest, most ductile | Chemical equipment, seawater desalination |
| Grade 2 | 99.2% Ti | Moderate strength, most commonly used | Medical implants, construction |
| Grade 3 | 99.1% Ti | Higher strength | Aerospace structural parts |
| Grade 4 | 99.0% Ti | Highest strength pure titanium | High pressure vessels, orthopedic implants |
(2) Titanium alloy (enhanced mechanical properties)
| Alloy type | Composition | Characteristics | Application |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ti-6Al-4V（Grade 5） | Titanium + 6% aluminum + 4% vanadium | Most widely used, high strength, heat resistance | Aircraft engines, artificial joints |
| Ti-6Al-2Sn-4Zr-2Mo | Titanium + aluminum + tin + zirconium + molybdenum | High temperature stability | Jet engine parts |
| Ti-3Al-2.5V | Titanium + 3% aluminum + 2.5% vanadium | Easy to process, corrosion resistance | Aviation hydraulic pipes, bicycle frames |
| Ti-5Al-2.5Sn | Titanium + 5% aluminum + 2.5% tin | Good weldability | Spacecraft structure |
(3) Other special titanium alloys
β titanium alloy (such as Ti-10V-2Fe-3Al): ultra-high strength, used for aviation landing gear.
Shape memory titanium alloy (such as Ti-Ni alloy): used for medical stents and smart materials.
What are the applications of Titanium ?
Titanium and its alloys have been widely used in many fields due to their high strength, low density, corrosion resistance, high temperature stability and good biocompatibility. The following table summarizes their applications:
| Field | Specific applications |
|---|---|
| Aerospace | Aircraft fuselage, engine blades, rocket shells |
| Medical | Artificial joints, dental implants, surgical instruments |
| Chemicals | Corrosion-resistant reactors, seawater desalination equipment |
| Military | Submarine pressure hulls, armor materials |
| Sporting goods | Golf clubs, bicycles, mountaineering equipment |
| Electronics | High-end mobile phone/laptop shells |
What is Tungsten?
Tungsten (chemical symbol W, from its German name Wolfram) is a hard, steel-gray metal known for its extremely high density and the highest melting point of any metal. This property makes tungsten indispensable in extremely hot applications, such as light bulb filaments (the metal must reach a white-hot state without melting).It is element number 74 on the periodic table. In nature, tungsten does not usually exist in its pure state, but is found in minerals such as wolframite and scheelite. Extracting pure tungsten metal requires processing these ores into tungsten oxide, which is then reduced with carbon or hydrogen at high temperatures.
If you’ve encountered tungsten in your daily life, it’s probably tungsten carbide, one of the hardest materials used to make cutting tools and wear-resistant jewelry. Tungsten is so hard that it can be used to make drills and saw blades capable of cutting other metals.
What are the characteristics of Tungsten ?
Tungsten is a metal with unique properties, its properties are mainly:
(1) Physical Properties
| Properties | Numerical value/description |
|---|---|
| Density | 19.25 g/cm³ (close to the density of gold, 4.3 times as dense as titanium) |
| Melting point | 3422°C (6192°F, the highest of all metals) |
| Boiling point | 5555°C（10031°F） |
| Hardness | 7.5 on the Mohs hardness scale (for pure tungsten), tungsten carbide can be up to 9.0-9.5 |
| Conductivity | Good (about 1/3 of copper, but excellent in high temperature resistance) |
| Coefficient of thermal expansion | Very low (4.5 x 10-⁶/K, dimensionally stable at high temperatures) |
(2) Chemical properties
Corrosion resistance: Stable to water and air at room temperature, but easily oxidized at high temperature (forming WO₃).
Acid and alkali resistance: Resistant to dilute acid corrosion, but soluble in a mixture of nitric acid and hydrofluoric acid.
(3) Mechanical properties
High tensile strength: Maintains strength at high temperatures (3 times that of steel at 1000°C).
Brittleness: Pure tungsten is relatively brittle at room temperature and needs to be improved by alloying or powder metallurgy.
What are the different types of Tungsten?
The classification of tungsten is mainly based on purity, alloy composition and processing form:
(1) Pure tungsten
| Grade | Purity | Characteristics | Application |
|---|---|---|---|
| Industrial pure tungsten | 99.95% | High melting point, arc erosion resistance | Filament, electrode |
| High purity tungsten | ≥99.99% | Low impurities, excellent electronic properties | Semiconductor target, nuclear industry |
(2) Tungsten alloy
| Alloy type | Composition | Characteristics | Application |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tungsten steel (hard alloy) | WC + Co/Ni/Fe | Superhard, wear-resistant | Cutting tools, drill bits |
| High-density tungsten alloy | W（90-97%）+ Ni/Fe/Cu | High density, radiation-resistant | Armor-piercing projectiles, counterweights |
| Tungsten copper alloy | W + Cu | High conductivity + high temperature resistance | Electrical contacts, rocket nozzles |
| Tungsten rhenium alloy | W + Re（3-26%） | Improved ductility | High-temperature thermocouples, aerospace components |
(3) Tungsten compounds
| Type | Chemical formula | Properties | Applications |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tungsten carbide（WC） | WC | Hardness close to diamond | Tool coating, wear-resistant parts |
| Tungsten oxide（WO₃） | WO₃ | Electrochromic properties | Smart glass, catalysts |
| Tungsten disulfide （WS₂） | WS₂ | Excellent lubricity | High-temperature lubricants, nanomaterials |
What are the applications of Tungsten?
Tungsten has been widely used in many fields due to its high melting point, high strength, high hardness, good electrical conductivity and thermal conductivity. The following table is a detailed introduction:
| Field | Specific application |
|---|---|
| Industrial manufacturing | Carbide tools, molds, wear-resistant parts |
| Electronic and electrical | Filaments, semiconductor chips, X-ray targets |
| Military defense | Armor-piercing cores, armor materials, rocket nozzles |
| Energy | Nuclear fusion device inner wall materials, radiation shielding |
| Medical | Radiotherapy shielding, surgical instrument counterweights |
| Aerospace | High temperature engine components, satellite balance weights |
Titanium vs. Tungsten: What’s the Difference?
The following is a summary table of the main differences between Titanium and Tungsten:
| Characteristics | Titanium (Ti) | Tungsten (W) |
|---|---|---|
| Atomic number | 22 | 74 |
| Density | 4.506 g/cm³ (light metal) | 19.25 g/cm³ (heavy metal) |
| Melting point | 1668°C | 3422°C (highest among all metals) |
| Hardness | Mohs hardness about 6 (soft) | Mohs hardness about 7.5 (extremely hard) |
| Corrosion resistance | Very strong (acid, alkali, seawater corrosion resistant) | Stable at room temperature, easy to oxidize at high temperature |
| Electrical/thermal conductivity | Low | High (conductivity close to steel, good thermal conductivity) |
| Ductility | Good (strong machinability) | High brittleness (forgeable at high temperature) |
| Main uses | Aerospace, medical implants, chemical equipment | Filaments, cutting tools, armor-piercing bullets, high-temperature alloys |
| Price | High (but lower than tungsten) | Expensive (high mining and purification costs) |
| Biocompatibility | Excellent (non-toxic, not rejected by the human body) | General (heavy metal, long-term contact may be harmful) |
Key Differences:
- Density and Weight: Titanium is lightweight, tungsten is extremely heavy.
- High Temperature Resistance: Tungsten’s melting point and high temperature strength far exceeds that of titanium.
- Applications: Titanium favors biological and corrosion-resistant scenarios, tungsten is used in extreme environments (e.g., high temperatures, high hardness requirements).
- Processing Difficulty: Titanium is easy to process, tungsten requires special processes (e.g. powder metallurgy).
Titanium vs. Tungsten: How to Choose?
Both metals have their own advantages and disadvantages, and it ultimately depends on your project priorities and usage scenarios. Here are some selection guidelines:
1. Choose titanium when:
- Lightweight and corrosion-resistant structural parts are needed (such as aircraft frames, diving equipment).
- Biomedical or human contact products (such as implants, eyeglass frames).
- Mid- to high-end consumer products where the budget allows (such as high-end watches, outdoor equipment).
2.Choose tungsten when:
- Parts in extreme high temperature environments (such as spacecraft propulsion systems).
- High-density demand scenarios (such as racing weights, radiation-proof containers).
- Wear-resistant tools (need to be made into carbide with cobalt, carbon, etc., such as WC-Co tools).
How big is the difference in machining costs between titanium and tungsten?
In the field of metal processing, titanium (Ti) and tungsten (W) are both high-performance materials, but their processing costs vary greatly. From machining energy consumption to surface finishing costs, each item will affect the pricing of the final product. LS will compare energy consumption, tool loss, and finishing cost to help you accurately choose the right material!
1. Machining energy consumption ratio
① Titanium (Ti) has high energy consumption during machining and requires argon protection
- Power consumption: 3.2 kWh/kg (3 times higher than ordinary steel)
- Special requirements: Titanium is easy to react with oxygen and nitrogen at high temperatures, and must be protected by argon, otherwise it will become brittle.
- Slow machining speed: Titanium has poor thermal conductivity, which can easily cause tool overheating, and the cutting speed needs to be reduced.
② Tungsten (W) has low energy consumption during machining, but tool loss is extremely high
- Power consumption: 0.8 kWh/kg (75% lower than titanium)
- Tool loss rate: 400% (4 times that of ordinary steel)
Tungsten has extremely high hardness, and ordinary tools are extremely easy to wear, so diamond or carbide tools must be used.
Frequent tool changes increase downtime and indirectly increase costs.
Conclusion: Titanium machining consumes a lot of energy, but tungsten machining tools cost more!
2. Comparison of finishing costs
① Titanium surface finishing: anodizing (¥80/piece)
- Process: electrolytic coloring to form a wear-resistant and corrosion-resistant oxide layer.
- Advantages: low cost, customizable colors (such as titanium alloy watches, 3C products).
- Disadvantages: may fail in high temperature environments (>300°C).
② Tungsten surface finishing: CVD coating (¥500/piece)
- Process: chemical vapor deposition (CVD), tungsten carbide or diamond coating.
- Advantages: super hard, high temperature resistant (>1000°C without falling off).
- Disadvantages: expensive equipment, complex process, and the cost per piece is 6 times that of titanium!
Conclusion: The finishing cost of tungsten is much higher than that of titanium, and it is only suitable for high-end industrial applications (such as aircraft engines and precision molds).
3. Comprehensive cost analysis
| Cost items | Titanium (Ti) | Tungsten (W) |
|---|---|---|
| Machining power consumption | 3.2 kWh/kg (high) | 0.8 kWh/kg (low) |
| Tool loss | Medium (special tools required) | Extremely high (400% wear rate) |
| Surface treatment cost | ¥80/piece (anodizing) | ¥500/piece (CVD coating) |
| Suitable industries | Medical, aerospace, 3C | Military industry, high-end molds, nuclear industry |
Final suggestion:
Limited budget + lightweight requirements? Choose titanium!
Extreme wear resistance/high temperature resistance? Choose tungsten, but be prepared to spend money!
Conclusion
Although both titanium and tungsten are high-performance metals, their properties are completely different: titanium is known for its light weight, corrosion resistance and biocompatibility, and is suitable for aerospace, medical and consumer electronics fields; tungsten is known for its ultra-high density, high temperature resistance and extreme hardness, and is more suitable for military industry, high-temperature equipment and wear-resistant tools. If you are looking for low cost, easy processing and corrosion resistance, titanium is an ideal choice; if you need to withstand extreme environments or high-density counterweights, tungsten is better. In the end, weighing performance and cost according to specific scenarios can make the best decision!
📞 Phone: +86 185 6675 9667
📧 Email: info@longshengmfg.com
🌐 Website: https://www.longshengmfg.com/
Disclaimer
The content appearing on this webpage is for informational purposes only. LS makes no representation or warranty of any kind, be it expressed or implied, as to the accuracy, completeness, or validity of the information. Any performance parameters, geometric tolerances, specific design features, quality and types of materials, or processes should not be inferred to represent what will be delivered by third-party suppliers or manufacturers through LS’s network. Buyers seeking quotes for parts are responsible for defining the specific requirements for those parts. Please contact to our for more information.
Team LS
This article was written by various LS contributors. LS is a leading resource on manufacturing with CNC machining, sheet metal fabrication, 3D printing, injection molding,metal stamping and more.
FAQs
What is the difference between titanium and tungsten?
Titanium is a lightweight (density 4.5g/cm³), corrosion-resistant, biocompatible metal commonly used in aerospace and medical fields; while tungsten is an extremely heavy (density 19.3g/cm³), high melting point (3422°C), high hardness metal, mainly used for high-temperature tools, armor-piercing shells and radiation shielding. In addition, titanium has poor thermal conductivity but good welding performance, while tungsten has excellent electrical and thermal conductivity but is difficult to process. There is also a significant difference in price between the two, with titanium material prices usually 1/3 to 1/2 of tungsten.
What are the disadvantages of tungsten?
The main disadvantages of tungsten are that it is difficult to process (high hardness leads to rapid tool wear), it is brittle at room temperature, it is easy to oxidize at high temperature, and its high density increases the weight burden. It is particularly noteworthy that tungsten has a low recrystallization temperature (about 1200°C), and it is easy to coarsen grains during high-temperature use, resulting in a decrease in mechanical properties. In addition, pure tungsten has extremely poor ductility, and it is usually necessary to add rare earth oxides (such as La2O3) or use powder metallurgy to improve performance.
How to identify titanium?
Titanium can be identified by the following methods: ① weighing it (obviously lighter than steel); ② non-magnetic; ③ the surface can be anodized to produce color; ④ professional testing such as XRF spectroscopy or spark testing (titanium sparks are bright white); ⑤ nitric acid corrosion resistance (no reaction after dropping nitric acid). More accurate methods include measuring resistivity (titanium is about 42μΩ·cm) or performing hardness tests (pure titanium Vickers hardness is about 100-120HV). Spectroscopic analysis is also often used in industry for rapid and accurate identification.
How to identify tungsten?
Tungsten can be identified by comprehensive judgment through the following methods: ① Measure density (the density of tungsten is as high as 19.3g/cm³, which is obviously heavier than most metals); ② Observe appearance (pure tungsten is steel gray and an oxide film is easily formed on the surface); ③ Test hardness (Mohs hardness 7.5, can scratch glass); ④ Conduct high temperature resistance test (tungsten can still maintain its shape at 1000℃); ⑤ Professional detection (X-ray fluorescence spectroscopy analysis can accurately determine the tungsten content, or use spark test, tungsten sparks are dark red and short-lived); ⑥ Chemical detection (tungsten is insoluble in hydrochloric acid and sulfuric acid, but soluble in a mixture of nitric acid and hydrofluoric acid).
